“It was as if gravity had pulled us both here, to this place at this exact time, and I couldn’t seem to defy the force of it. I couldn’t ignore the significance.”
Wow!!
This was SUCH a good book! An unconventional romance with a powerful emotional impact. I loved it!!
I honestly don’t know how to describe this story to you though without it being misleading because there is a huge twist that literally changes everything you know!! Like, really — woah!! Technically, even the blurb actually makes make you “think” the story is something it’s not. So it’s hard to talk about…
PS – this whole review page is spoiler-free.
I’ll admit that I actually knew the twist before I started and here’s the thing: There are many different kinds of readers out there. Some of you love going into books completely blind and being taken by surprise by the twists… and there are others who like to know exactly what to expect from this kind of story.
Just for me, personally, I’ll be honest and say that if I had been taken by surprise by this twist, I would have disliked the book. This is not a fault of the author or the way the book is presented, it is just a reflection of the type of reader I am. This isn’t me telling you what you will or won’t feel, just me saying that for this kind of big, game-changing twist, I prefer going in with an understanding of what to expect because it gives me a sense of security. Knowing what to expect did not in any way dull the emotional impact of the twist. Guys, I CRIED. Over and over and over again, even though I knew what was coming.
And also… again, just for me, the minute I heard what the twist was, it made me want to drop everything and read the book NOW. So finding out was actually the thing that made me read the book!
So, I’m not telling you what to do. If you want to go in blind, do it!! Many readers recommend doing that, in fact. However, many other readers have told me that they are so grateful that they were told in advance and that knowing the twist made them able to love the book. So the choice is YOURS.
If you want to know the twist (full spoilers), click this link here.
____________
Ok, I should probably actually review this a little now, huh? (still spoiler-free!)
I really enjoyed the story right from the start — that prologue was heart-wrenching! I think it especially helped my anticipation because I knew the direction it was heading in. Honestly, I did find the first half of the book though to be a little slow — no crazy emotions or anything like that — it just seemed like a normal story. But I knew what was coming and I knew what was really happening and so that kept me flipping pages as fast as I could because I wanted to experience the impact of the twist and when it hit, I totally fell apart! Big crocodile tears just streamed down my face. Then I’d be okay for a few pages and then tears would start all over again!! And it was real mascara-running, throat-closing-up, cant-see-the-page crying.
I LOVE BIG EMOTIONS. I want to feel the stories I read in my heart and oh boy did I ever feel this one.
This wasn’t just a simple “boy meets girl” romance. The relationship dynamics between past and present and between the different aspects of her life were quite complex. There were secrets that had been hidden for years and a lot of drama and big life choices that felt very “real”. And I really appreciated that because real life isn’t always simple, it isn’t always clear, it isn’t always fair and I loved seeing the characters work through these issues. This story was undoubtedly unconventional but I applaud the author for stepping outside the box and writing this story because it left such a strong impression on my heart!!
Definitely a new favorite!!
Rating: 4.5 stars!! Standalone Contemporary Romance.
Danielle says
LOVED this book!!!! I ugly cried but it was so worth it!
Aestas says
I agree!! So worth it 🙂
Ava says
Thank you so much for the explanation 🙂 Cant wait to read this now!
Aestas says
You’re very welcome! I’m so glad it helped 🙂
Melissa says
Thanks for the great review, Aestas! I couldn’t agree more about being a certain type of reader and reading this book. I knew there was a twist, but must have missed the spoilers because I one-clicked it before I knew what was coming. While it wouldn’t have changed my desire to read it, I wish I had a heads up before jumping in. That said, it was a beautiful, heartbreaking story. I rehashed the whole story to my poor husband, who just nodded and patted my shoulder. A testament to Cedergreen’s writing that I was so invested. I have encouraged my friends to read it, but with fair warning to be emotionally prepared. Finally, Cedergreen’s ability to set a scene (namely the lake house) is really inspiring. Her scenic descriptions really made me feel like I was in the scene with the characters.
Aestas says
It really was a beautiful story. I totally agree 🙂
Swaths says
Unlike you I decided to go blind to this story. Based on your review I thought about a lot of stuff and found that all my theories were actually not possible. It ranged from It was actually Drew who actually did the deed to Drew was the one who brought Ryan to Gem’s life to Ryan and Drew are the same person. As you can see all these ideas were quite impossible in real life but actual twist was like impossible but then you never know what happens in the realms of mind you know ! all in all a good story and i definitely enjoyed the writing. As I said earlier, i do like your selections and trust your ratings. I have had Mia Sheridan’s books for quite some time so probably heeding your advice I will go read it next ! thanks for the great review as always….
Aestas says
I’m so glad you enjoyed it!!!
And, Mia’s books are amazing — definitely read them next. You’re in for a big treat with those 😀